Concrete vs Asphalt Driveways: What’s Best for Albany Homeowners?

Written By Dane McKeehan

Thinking about replacing your driveway but stuck between asphalt and concrete? In the Capital Region, the weather alone makes the choice a bit easier. Here’s a full breakdown of the pros and cons — and why most Albany homeowners ultimately go with asphalt.

Talk to a driveway expert today »

The Basics: What You’re Choosing Between

Concrete

  • Light gray in appearance

  • Takes longer to install and cure

  • More expensive upfront

  • Known for its clean look

Asphalt

  • Jet-black when fresh, fades to charcoal

  • Fast installation (1–2 days)

  • More flexible under pressure

  • Easier and cheaper to repair

Both materials can work, but in Albany’s weather conditions? One clearly handles the elements better.

Upstate NY Weather: The Real Decider

Albany winters are no joke. The freeze-thaw cycle expands and contracts the surface dozens of times a season.

  • Concrete is rigid — it cracks more easily when moisture gets in and freezes.

  • Asphalt is flexible — it expands and contracts with temperature changes.

For homeowners dealing with ice, snowplows, and salt, asphalt is built for this climate.

Repairs & Maintenance

  • Asphalt can be patched, resurfaced, or sealcoated easily.

  • Concrete repairs are often more noticeable, and full replacement sections are costly.

Asphalt lets you manage wear-and-tear over time — instead of all at once.

Curb Appeal & Customization

Some homeowners prefer the lighter look of concrete or stamped finishes. But asphalt’s clean, dark finish provides a classic look that fits almost any home style — especially after fresh compaction.

Bonus: asphalt blends in with city curb lines, drive approaches, and sidewalks more smoothly.

What Most Albany Homeowners Choose

In our 50+ years of paving driveways across Albany, Colonie, and Troy, asphalt is hands-down the most popular — and practical — choice.

Unless you have a specific architectural reason or climate-controlled plan for concrete, asphalt delivers more value in this region.

Final Thought

Concrete has its place — but in Upstate New York, where the elements take a toll, asphalt gives homeowners the best balance of price, performance, and peace of mind.

Talk to us about your project — and get a free estimate today »

Internal Resources:

Residential Paving Services

https://www.eganpaving.net/services/residential

Drainage & Grading

https://www.eganpaving.net/services/grading

Contact Page

https://www.eganpaving.net/contact

Dane McKeehan
Next

The Hidden Costs of Cheap Paving: What Capital Region Homeowners Regret Most